Skip to content
Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream
The Scoop · Cakes & Parties

Thanksgiving Ice Cream Cakes in Monmouth County: Pumpkin, Maple Walnut, and When to Order

· By the Ryan's team

Chocolate crunch sheet ice cream cake from Ryan's with whipped cream border

Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26 this year, and somebody at your table is going to say they are too full for pie and then eat ice cream anyway. An ice cream cake built from the fall flavors settles the pie-versus-cake argument, feeds a crowd without an oven, and shows up ready to serve. Here is how to build one and when to order it.

Fall flavors that belong on the Thanksgiving table

Every Ryan's cake is made from the same small-batch ice cream in the case, and in November the seasonal case is built for exactly this meal. The fall lineup is Pumpkin, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Maple Walnut, Cinnamon, and Caramel Apple. A cake has a top layer, a middle, and a bottom layer, so you get to pair them:

  • Pumpkin over Vanilla with a Chocolate Crunchies middle. The pumpkin pie of ice cream cakes, and the safest pick for a mixed table.
  • Maple Walnut over Coffee with a Fudge middle. Tastes like the end of the meal: coffee, something sweet, and a nap.
  • Caramel Apple over Cinnamon with a Crushed Oreo Cookie middle. Apple pie energy for the house that always has two apple pies anyway.
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake over Chocolate with a Rainbow Sprinkles middle. The one the kids' table votes for.

Vanilla and chocolate layers and the Chocolate Crunchies middle are no charge. Other flavors and middles add a small amount based on the size of the cake, and the online order form shows a running estimate while you build. Seasonal flavors can run out, so have a second choice ready when the shop calls to confirm.

Pick a size for your head count

Six sizes cover everything from a quiet dinner to the whole extended family. Round cakes run 7-inch (serves 6 to 8), 8-inch (8 to 10), 9-inch (10 to 12), and 10-inch (12 to 15). For a big Thanksgiving, the half sheet serves 20 to 28 and the full sheet 30 to 45. Remember that the cake is competing with pie, so most people cut smaller slices than they would at a birthday. A 9-inch round comfortably handles a table of 12 that also has dessert options. The cakes page has the full size and price table.

Decorating for a grown-up holiday

Thanksgiving cakes tend to be simpler than birthday cakes. Orange or yellow writing with "Happy Thanksgiving" or the family name, a classic shell border or whipped cream swirls, and maybe Walnuts or Toasted Coconut from the topping board. Caramel drizzle over a Pumpkin cake is the move if you want one flourish. The form also has gluten-free (made without crunchies) and frozen yogurt options at no extra charge, for the relative who always asks.

When to order: Cakes need at least 48 hours' notice, so the absolute latest to order for Thanksgiving Day is Tuesday, November 24. We recommend ordering the weekend before, and picking up on Wednesday, November 25, so the holiday itself is not a shop run. Check our Google listing for Thanksgiving Day hours before planning a Thursday pickup. Order online or call Tinton Falls at (732) 842-5874. Pickups are at our Tinton Falls shop, since Oakhurst is closed for the season.

Getting it home and keeping it frozen

Pick up the day before, go straight home, and put the cake in the freezer in its box. Pull it out about 10 to 15 minutes before dessert so it slices cleanly. Our guide to how long an ice cream cake lasts covers freezer storage and what to do with leftovers, which there usually are not. If you are traveling to the dinner, a cooler with ice packs holds a cake for a reasonable drive across Monmouth County.

Order a Thanksgiving Cake →

Back to all posts

Keep reading

More from The Scoop

Cakes & Parties

Ice Cream Cake for a Party: Feeding the Whole Team

End-of-summer send-offs, back-to-school bashes, the first team parties of fall: here's how to size an ice cream cake for your crowd and get it ordered in time.

Read the post
Cakes & Parties

You Can Now Order Ryan's Ice Cream Cakes Online

The cakes are still made and decorated by hand at the shop. The only thing that changed is how easy it is to start one: our new online order form is open any hour you are.

Read the post
The best time for ice cream is always!