Skip to content
Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream
Ryan's Ice Cream

Homemade Ice Cream in Monmouth County, NJ

Small-batch ice cream made in our own Jersey Shore shops since 1988. 24+ everyday flavors, rotating seasonal specials, and a counter in Tinton Falls and Oakhurst that is open daily until 10 PM.

Flight sampler of four homemade ice cream flavors in front of Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream
scooped by hand

24+ Homemade Flavors

The everyday board at both shops. Made fresh in small batches; availability may vary by location and timing.

The Classics

Vanilla

The one everything else is measured against, and the base for most sundaes and shakes.

Vanilla Fudge

Vanilla ice cream with a ribbon of fudge running through it.

Cherry Vanilla

Vanilla ice cream with cherries.

Strawberry

Pink, fruity, and a first-visit favorite.

Cookies and Cream

Cream ice cream loaded with chocolate sandwich cookie pieces.

Cookie Dough

Ice cream with chunks of cookie dough in every scoop.

Butter Pecan

Buttery ice cream with pecans. Regulars swear by it.

Salted Caramel

Caramel ice cream with a touch of salt.

Chocolate & Peanut Butter

Chocolate

Straight-up chocolate ice cream.

Fudge Brownie

Chocolate ice cream with brownie pieces.

3X Chocolate

Chocolate three ways for the true devotee.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch

Chocolate and peanut butter with a crunch.

Rocky Road

Chocolate ice cream with marshmallow and nuts.

Reese's Blast

A blast of Reese's peanut butter cup pieces.

Reese's Peanut Butter

Peanut butter ice cream with Reese's.

Chocolate Cherry

Chocolate ice cream with cherries.

Chocolate Strawberry

Chocolate ice cream with strawberry.

Fruity & Fun

Raspberry Bomb

Big, bold raspberry flavor.

Banana

Banana ice cream, simple and sweet.

Lemon Sherbert

Light and tart, the refreshing pick on a hot day.

Fruity Pebbles

Ice cream with Fruity Pebbles cereal mixed in.

Coffee & Mint

Mint Chip

Mint ice cream with chocolate chips.

Coffee

Coffee ice cream for the grown-ups.

Coffee Chip

Coffee ice cream with chocolate chips.

Right now

Seasonal: Jersey Peach, Strawberry Cheesecake, Elvis

See Seasonal Flavors →
behind the counter

What "homemade" means at Ryan's

Plenty of shops put the word on the sign. Here it means the ice cream is made in small batches in our own shops, not shipped in by the pallet. Small batches mean the flavors in the case turn over constantly, so the scoop in your cone was made recently, not months ago.

Making it ourselves is also why the board can hold 24 flavors at once, from Butter Pecan and Vanilla Fudge to Fruity Pebbles and Raspberry Bomb, plus whatever is seasonal. When you make it yourself, you decide the lineup. And because everything starts in-house, the whole menu benefits: every milkshake is hand-spun from these same flavors, and the pints and quarts we pack to go come from the very same batches.

Ryan's has been family owned and making ice cream this way since 1988. Nearly four decades of Monmouth County families coming back is the most honest quality control there is.

Ways to enjoy it

Cones & cups

A scoop or two of any flavor, in a cup, a cake cone, or a waffle cone. The simplest way to taste the difference.

Sundaes

Start with your favorite flavor, then add toppings, sauces, and whipped cream.

Flights

Can't decide? A flight lets you sample several flavors in one order (pictured above). Or let the Flavor Wheel choose.

Milkshakes & floats

Any flavor in the case, hand-spun to order and topped with whipped cream.

Take-home quarts

Hand-packed or pre-packed quarts for movie nights and parties. Pints too.

Ice cream cakes

Built by hand with the flavors you pick. Order a cake with 48 hours' notice.

Looking for something lighter or dairy-free? Our Italian ice and 100% dairy-free Dole fruit soft serve share the same counter. Novelty treats like Chippers use this same homemade ice cream, too.

straight from the case

Real scoops, real photos

Double scoop of homemade fudge brownie ice cream on a waffle cone Mint chocolate chip ice cream piled high on a homemade waffle cone Homemade vanilla ice cream stacked high on a waffle cone Bright pink strawberry ice cream double scoop on a cone Fresh banana ice cream scooped on a waffle cone Ice cream topped with a thick peanut butter swirl in a yellow cup
good to know

Homemade ice cream questions

Is Ryan's ice cream really made in-house?

Yes. Ryan's has made its own ice cream in small batches since 1988, and everything in the case comes from those batches, not from a warehouse. Small batches mean the flavors turn over constantly, so what you're scooping was made recently.

How many homemade flavors does Ryan's have?

The everyday board runs 24 homemade flavors, from Vanilla and Butter Pecan to Fruity Pebbles and Coffee Chip. On top of that, a rotating seasonal lineup like Jersey Peach comes and goes with the calendar.

Do you have dairy-free or vegan options?

Yes. Ryan's serves 100% dairy-free Dole fruit soft serve in pineapple, strawberry, and cherry, and our Italian ice is dairy-free too. Availability can vary by location and season.

Can I take homemade ice cream home?

Yes. We hand-pack pints and quarts at the counter in any flavor in the case, and pre-packed quarts are ready to grab from the freezer. Pre-packed flavors rotate, so it's worth calling ahead. See our take-home quarts page for details.

Where is the closest Ryan's to Red Bank or Long Branch?

From Red Bank, Shrewsbury, or Eatontown, head to our Tinton Falls shop at 462 Shrewsbury Ave (under 10 minutes from Red Bank). From Long Branch, Asbury Park, or Ocean Township, our Oakhurst shop at 1805 NJ-35 is the closer stop. Our Hazlet shop is temporarily closed.

Can I get Ryan's ice cream delivered?

Our Tinton Falls shop delivers through DoorDash, so homemade ice cream can reach you on the nights the couch wins. Ice cream cakes are ordered separately and picked up at the shop.

More answers on our FAQ page.

two Shore shops

Find your nearest scoop

Both shops scoop the same homemade lineup, so the right one is simply whichever is closer.

Tinton Falls

462 Shrewsbury Ave
Tinton Falls, NJ 07701

Open daily · 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

(732) 842-5874

Oakhurst

1805 NJ-35
Oakhurst, NJ 07755

Open daily · 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM

(732) 517-0000
The best time for ice cream is always!