Ice Cream in Tinton Falls, NJ

Homemade Ice Cream on Shrewsbury Avenue

Our Tinton Falls shop on Shrewsbury Avenue is the original home base for Ryan's, just off Route 35 and a short drive from Red Bank, Eatontown, and Shrewsbury. It's a favorite after-dinner stop for Monmouth County families, with a full case of small-batch flavors churned right here since 1988.

Swing by for a hand-scooped cone, a thick hand-spun milkshake, a pre-packed quart to take home, or a custom ice cream cake for the next birthday or graduation. You'll also find seasonal flavors, Italian ice, novelty treats, and dairy-free Dole fruit soft serve. Browse the full flavor menu or order an ice cream cake.

Picking up an ice cream cake here

Tinton Falls is one of two pickup shops for our custom ice cream cakes. Start your cake order online — choose your flavors, middle layer, and cake writing, pick Tinton Falls as your shop, and give us at least 48 hours' notice. We call to confirm every order before we start decorating, so there are no surprises on party day.

Taking Ryan's home with you

The freezer case is stocked for more than a cone at the counter. Grab a hand-packed quart of any flavor we're scooping, a box of Chippers or Saucers for the freezer at home, or one of our novelty treats for the kids. Bringing the dog? Ask for a pup cup. Rather stay on the couch? This shop delivers through DoorDash, and gift cards are available online — good at both of our open shops.