Skip to content
Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream
Ryan's Ice Cream

Hand-Spun Milkshakes

Thick, creamy, and spun to order from our own homemade ice cream. Pick any of 24+ flavors at our Tinton Falls shop, minutes from Red Bank, Shrewsbury, and the rest of Monmouth County (Oakhurst reopens in the spring).

Hand-spun milkshake topped with whipped cream, chocolate drizzle and a cherry Hand-spun milkshake next to a cup of homemade ice cream Root beer float made with homemade vanilla ice cream Hand-spun milkshake from Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream
Spun to order

What "hand-spun" means at Ryan's

A hand-spun shake starts the same way a cone does: with scoops of homemade ice cream straight from the case. We blend it to order, thick and creamy, then top it with whipped cream so it is cold, smooth, and ready to go. There is no pre-mixed shake base and no shortcut, just the same small-batch ice cream we have been making in-house since 1988, turned into something you drink through a straw (eventually).

That is the whole difference between a milkshake made from real ice cream and the kind poured out of a machine. When the ice cream is good on its own, the shake takes care of itself.

Any homemade flavor becomes a shake

The best milkshake starts with ice cream you already love, and at Ryan's you get to pick from the entire board. Choose something classic, something fruity, something rich, or whatever seasonal flavor is scooping that week. A few ideas to get you started:

Vanilla shake

The classic diner shake, and the base for a float.

Chocolate shake

Thick, rich, and the most-requested kind for a reason.

Strawberry shake

Fruity and pink, made from strawberry ice cream, not syrup.

Cookies and Cream shake

Cookie pieces blended right through the shake.

Coffee shake

A cold coffee pick-me-up for the grown-ups.

Mint Chip shake

Cool mint with chocolate chips in every sip.

Salted Caramel shake

Sweet and salty, and a natural with whipped cream on top.

Butter Pecan shake

Buttery, nutty, and a regulars' favorite.

And that is only a start. Every one of these homemade flavors can be spun into a shake:

Vanilla Vanilla Fudge Cherry Vanilla Strawberry Cookies and Cream Cookie Dough Butter Pecan Salted Caramel Chocolate Fudge Brownie 3X Chocolate Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch Rocky Road Raspberry Bomb Banana Lemon Sherbert Fruity Pebbles Reese's Blast Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cherry Chocolate Strawberry Mint Chip Coffee Coffee Chip

Old-fashioned floats, too

Not every craving is a milkshake craving. Alongside hand-spun shakes we make old-fashioned floats, like a root beer float built on a scoop of homemade vanilla (pictured above). Ask at the counter for what is available that day.

Pair it with the rest of your visit

A milkshake can be the main event or one part of a bigger Ryan's stop. Families often order cones and sundaes, Italian ice, dairy-free Dole soft serve, novelty treats, or a take-home quart while one person sips a shake. Because everything is made in house, it is easy to build an order that keeps the whole group happy.

Milkshakes near Red Bank, Long Branch, and the Shore

Our Tinton Falls shop at 462 Shrewsbury Ave is under 10 minutes from Red Bank, about 5 from Shrewsbury, and about 10 from Eatontown. It is open daily until 10:00 PM, so a late shake after dinner or a game is always on the table. Our Oakhurst shop at 1805 NJ-35 on Route 35 is closed for the season and reopens in the spring.

Find Your Location →
good to know

Milkshake questions

What flavors can I get in a milkshake?

Any homemade flavor in the case. That's 24 everyday flavors, from Vanilla and Chocolate to Coffee Chip and Fruity Pebbles, plus whatever seasonal flavor is on the board that week. If you can scoop it, we can shake it.

What does hand-spun mean?

It means your shake is made to order from scooped homemade ice cream, blended thick and creamy, and topped with whipped cream, rather than poured from a pre-mixed machine. Every shake starts with the same small-batch ice cream we scoop into cones.

Do you make floats?

Yes. Alongside hand-spun milkshakes we make old-fashioned floats, like a root beer float built on homemade vanilla ice cream. Ask at the counter for what's available that day.

Where can I get a milkshake near Red Bank or Long Branch?

From Red Bank, Shrewsbury, or Eatontown, our Tinton Falls shop at 462 Shrewsbury Ave is under 10 minutes away. Our Oakhurst shop on Route 35 is closed for the season, so Long Branch, Asbury Park, and Ocean Township shake runs go to Tinton Falls too. Our Hazlet shop is temporarily closed.

How late can I get a milkshake?

Tinton Falls is open daily from 11:00 AM until 10:00 PM, so the after-dinner shake window is always covered. Our Oakhurst shop is closed for the season and reopens in the spring. Hours can vary with the season, so call ahead for a late visit.

More answers on our FAQ page.

two Shore shops

Where to get your shake

Tinton Falls

462 Shrewsbury Ave
Tinton Falls, NJ 07701

Open daily · 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

(732) 842-5874
The best time for ice cream is always!