On Thanksgiving the oven belongs to the turkey, the stuffing, and whoever claimed the second rack for the sweet potatoes. Dessert has to come from somewhere else. The freezer case at Ryan's covers the whole table, from a quart for the pie to a sheet cake for thirty, and all of it is ready when you walk in. Here is how to build a Thanksgiving dessert spread without baking a thing.
Quarts for the pie
Start with the basics: a quart of Vanilla for every pie on the table, and a quart of something seasonal for the people who want a scoop on its own. Hand-packed quarts can be any flavor in the case, so Pumpkin Cheesecake, Maple Walnut, or Cinnamon all work, and you can split a quart between two flavors. Our pumpkin post has pairings for each kind of pie.
Tortonis and cannolis for the Italian-American table
If your Thanksgiving ends with espresso and a tray from the bakery, Ryan's homemade tortonis belong on it: individual cups topped with toasted coconut and a cherry, the way the Shore has served them for generations. Ice cream cannolis, with chocolate chips and rainbow sprinkles, are the other grab-and-go tray filler. Both come boxed to go from our novelty case, portion themselves, and need no knife, no plates, and no cleanup.
Party cups for the kids' table
Mini party cups topped with sprinkles and a cherry are the easiest kids' dessert of the year. Each one is a single serving, they come out of the freezer one at a time, and nobody has to negotiate slice sizes. They are also the answer for the cousin who does not like pie and will not say so.
A cake when the crowd is big
For a table of 15 or more, an ice cream cake is the simplest centerpiece. A 10-inch round serves 12 to 15, a half sheet 20 to 28, and a full sheet 30 to 45. Cakes need at least 48 hours' notice, and the Thanksgiving cakes post covers fall flavor pairings and order timing. Gluten-free cakes (made without crunchies) are available at no extra charge for the guest who needs one.
Friendsgiving counts too: Friendsgiving usually lands the weekend before the holiday, and it has the same oven problem with a smaller table. A hand-packed quart or two and a box of tortonis is the right amount for eight friends. If the group is bigger, a 9-inch cake with "Happy Friendsgiving" in orange letters is on the order form.
Logistics: when to pick up and how to store it
Pick everything up on Wednesday, November 25, and go straight home. Quarts and novelties go in the back of the freezer, the cake stays in its box. Pull the cake 10 to 15 minutes before serving; everything else comes out as needed. Check our Google listing for Thanksgiving Day hours before planning a Thursday run. Our Tinton Falls shop at 462 Shrewsbury Ave is open daily 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM leading up to the holiday, and you can call (732) 842-5874 with questions. Oakhurst is closed for the season.


