Pumpkin ice cream has a short season at Ryan's, and this is the heart of it. We make two versions each fall, people have strong opinions about which one is better, and the quarts start disappearing the week before Thanksgiving. Here is the difference between the two, what to pair with each pie, and how to lock in a quart for the holiday table.
Pumpkin vs. Pumpkin Cheesecake
Pumpkin is the straightforward one: a spiced pumpkin ice cream that tastes like the filling of a good pumpkin pie, made in small batches like everything else in the homemade case. It is the pick for people who want pumpkin to taste like pumpkin, and it plays well next to a scoop of Vanilla.
Pumpkin Cheesecake is richer and a little tangier, with the cheesecake flavor rounding out the spice. It stands alone in a cup better than plain Pumpkin does, and it makes the best milkshake of the fall lineup. If you are only trying one, the crew will usually point you here first and let you argue later.
Pie pairings from the fall case
The full fall lineup is Pumpkin, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Maple Walnut, Cinnamon, and Caramel Apple, plus the year-round flavors. A scoop on the side of a warm slice is the easiest upgrade on the Thanksgiving dessert table:
- Pumpkin pie: Vanilla, or Maple Walnut if you want to lean into it.
- Apple pie: Cinnamon or Caramel Apple. Vanilla is the classic, but Cinnamon is the one people remember.
- Pecan pie: Coffee or Butter Pecan. Coffee cuts the sweetness; Butter Pecan doubles down.
- Chocolate anything: Pumpkin Cheesecake. Trust us on this one.
Hand-packed or pre-packed: which quart to bring
Take-home quarts come two ways. Pre-packed quarts are ready in the freezer case and are the fastest grab on the way to dinner. Hand-packed quarts are scooped to order from the dipping case, which means you can pack any flavor that is in the case that day, including the seasonals, and even split a quart between two flavors. For Thanksgiving, a hand-packed quart of Pumpkin Cheesecake and a quart of Vanilla covers every pie on the table. Our quarts explainer has the full comparison.
Seasonal means seasonal: The fall flavors leave the case when the season turns, and the holiday flavors move in. If you want pumpkin in your freezer for Thanksgiving, pick up the quart in the week or two before and store it in the back of the freezer, not the door. A sealed quart holds its texture for a few weeks when it stays truly frozen.
Where to get it
Both pumpkins are at our Tinton Falls shop at 462 Shrewsbury Ave, open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Our Oakhurst shop is closed for the season and reopens in the spring. Call ahead at (732) 842-5874 if you are making a special trip for a specific flavor, since the seasonal case changes as batches sell through.


